Author
DG Marketing Team

October 14, 2025

Why Patient Phone Calls Are the Hidden Powerhouse of Private Medical Practices

October 14, 2025


In today’s fast-paced healthcare environment, the front office isn’t just answering phones—they’re responsible for the first impressions a patient has for a practice. For private dental and medical practices, how calls are handled can directly impact revenue, reputation, and patient retention, be it for appointment bookings or reschedules, insurance questions or billing questions.

Let’s unpack the key types of calls your front office handles daily—and how to get the most out of every patient-practice experience.

How to Increase Appointment Booking Rates Through Better Call Handling

Every new patient inquiry is a potential long-term relationship. But if your front office fumbles the first call, you may never get the chance to prove your clinical excellence.

Common Issues That Hurt Booking Rates:

  • Delayed call pickup or poor phone etiquette
  • Inability to clearly explain services, location, or availability
  • Failing to build trust or calm anxious patients (especially in dental practices)

Strategies to Convert More Calls to Appointments:

Use a soft script in a proactive, you might be surprised to learn that a simple, friendly, solutions-based tone that conveys confidence with phrases like “We’d love to take care of you” or “Let’s find a time that works best for you” works best when handling patient calls.

“While many think the formula for success is more complicated, we often find that a consistent, polite tone during calls is an indicator of the most successful outcome for dental and medical front office calls,” said Andre Phan, Vice President at Doctor Genius. “Companies that include politeness as part of their top focuses see more repeat customers…and even new customers as a result of reviews from long-term customers,” he added.

Marketing dollars can make up a large part of your practice’s budget. To ensure your methods are performing efficiently, train staff to always ask, “How did you hear about us?”— on calls. It doubles as a rapport builder while helping to produce a trend story for a marketing metric. Whether from search results, reviews, or social media, this will help to make the right decisions for where to focus your energies and your marketing budget.

Offer patients a clear next step to keep engagement and avoid confusion. Whether your staff needs to confirm, add to calendar, or remind patients of a task (i.e. send their insurance information), this lightens the load on the patient and eases any potential tension with them wondering about what comes next.

While some of these aspects may seem small and inconsequential, a professionally handled booking call turns interest into action—and action into revenue. With calls being the main lifeline to a medical (or dental) practice, practice owners and/or front office managers need to ensure that calls are handled properly in order to book more appointments, convert prospects into patients and create long-term customer relationships.

Reduce No-Shows and Late Cancellations With Smart Appointment Scheduling Strategies

Cancellations are inevitable—but mishandling of rescheduled appointments are avoidable. With the right monitoring and training, these calls are your moment to salvage lost time and protect the day’s productivity.

Common Rescheduling Mistakes:

  • Open-ended options stretch out patient care cycles
  • Gaps in the schedule reduce staff efficiency and clinic profitability
  • Patients may feel like their care isn’t prioritized

Best Practices to Reduce Scheduling Gaps:

  • When rescheduling, lead the conversation by mentioning specific, open availability: “We have an opening this Thursday morning or next Monday; late afternoon. Which works better?
  • Offer waitlist options for patients eager to be seen sooner
  • Reinforce the importance of maintaining care frequency, especially for ongoing treatments like cleanings, follow-ups, or therapy

When reviewing customer’s Call Insights, it’s clear that adding specific detail to the rescheduling suggestions go a long way to reduce the wait time to patients back in and keeps your front office team in control of the conversation. While some staff may feel intrusive for being “so forward,” reframe this so they can view themselves as being proactive and forthcoming with availability and possible solutions. When dental or medical practices consider rescheduling as a required part of the clinical journey, versus a calendar shuffle, they keep customers longer and more steadily have a full bookings calendar.

Handling Health Insurance and Billing Calls With Clarity and Compassion

“Insurance is one of the most common topics that get discussed among Dental and Medical Practices when we look into their Caller IQ reports,” confirmed Phan. “After common appointment-setting calls, billing and insurance questions are right up there,” he continued.

Billing and insurance questions are often where patients feel the most vulnerable. A clear, confident response from your team can turn their anxiety into peace-felt assurance—and prevent cancellations due to cost concern confusion.

Common Mistakes to Avoid:

  • Overuse of jargon (e.g., “deductibles,” “EOBs”) without patient-friendly explanations
  • Saying “I don’t know” about their insurance or bill without offering a follow-up
  • Passing patients between departments or failing to call back

Better insurance call-handling comes down to one thing: easily-accessible information. There are plenty of insurance nuances and critical pieces of information to know about what is or isn’t covered for a particular patient, for a specific procedure, and at a certain point in time. It’s unrealistic to think that your entire front office team can become experts for all insurance questions.

However, it is realistic to help your team answer insurance questions by creating a cheat sheet of the most commonly asked questions, or a cheat sheet with simple, plain-language definitions of key terms. Make sure they understand different customer examples for how insurance could be handled so they can give a heads up to patients.

Ideally, at at least one team member is well-versed in billing and insurance questions and plans you accept. Have that person train the rest of the team for what questions to ask to identify when a call needs to be forwarded on, or when they may be able to answer the question themselves. Worse comes to worst, create a culture in your practice to let your medical receptionists know that checking in and getting back to patients is a perfectly acceptable way to handle a call, as long as they follow through and connect back: “Let me verify that for you and call back by 3pm” or “You can expect an emailed breakdown within the hour.”

When financial questions are answered with clarity, patients feel respected—and stay loyal.

Why Phone Etiquette Is a Competitive Advantage for Dental and Medical Practices

For many private practices, the phone is the front door to welcoming in patients, new and old. Patients don’t necessarily commit to a practice by your credentials—they make that judgement based on how their call is handled. They’re looking for knowledgeable, timely—and above all—polite interactions when speaking with dental and medical teams.

A consistently courteous and confident front office approach leads to:

  • Higher appointment conversion rates
  • Fewer no-shows and more rescheduled visits
  • Stronger word-of-mouth and better online reviews

Going back to the point made earlier, marketing dollars add up quickly and so being able to leverage word-of-mouth marketing for free from satisfied customers is worth the effort from staff to create and ensure good customer experiences. It becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy to back up marketing dollars with clients and calls that come in actually book from a positive phone interaction, and obviously carrying that through to the office visit.

How can you monitor for politeness, though? While transcription services are available, reading through, line-by-line of every call is a daunting task. Some AI tools can go a step further but where practices really zero in on things like identifying politeness (or any of the matters in this blog) is when an AI-powered modeling tool is paired with a transcription analysis tool. This not only tells you what was said, but in what context and, further, what the outcome was.

In short, every call is a chance to show your value before the patient ever walks through the door.

Final Thought: Invest in the First Touchpoint—To Get More Appointments As the Final Outcome

Great clinical care is your foundation. But it’s your front office’s ability to listen, guide, and reassure patients over the phone that often ultimately determines if patients ever get to experience that care.

Improving your practice’s performance starts by demystifying (and solidifying) the front office call. Going a step deeper, empowering your team to own the results of their own phone conduct with skill and confidence takes training and ongoing practice.

Caller IQ from Doctor Genius helps do exactly that: it identifies where your team is doing well and what are areas for improvement. It starts by first assessing each call, analyzing speech and context, understanding the outcome, and then providing a high-level assessment of the call so call receptionists and front office managers alike can pinpoint issues (or celebrate successes).

Whether used alone or in conjunction with the larger Doctor Genius platform, dental and medical offices are seeing more booked appointments, from both new and current patients. By accessing easy-to-use reporting on call performance and outcomes, practices are able to target specific areas of focus (politeness, insurance questions, offering specific availability, etc.) as ways to elevate their practice’s best practices.

Get a free demo and see how your practice could benefit from AI-powered call analysis.

demo-section-img